In the sequel to Garlic Bread for Eugene, Henry and Eugene learn at Alice's lemonade stand that the Hutchinsons' house and land is in bank foreclosure. The news is so distressing that Eugene solicits his older brother to do something. Is a seventh grader able to stop the sheriff from auctioning off the property? Will Butchie, the school janitor, join the cause after his life takes an unexpected turn during a date with Gail Paisley?