Carly Blosser may not match the typical description of a conservative Mennonite woman—unmarried at 27, living alone, and careening around her Oregon neighborhood on a pink bicycle—but she has a soft heart for the elderly Mennonite residents at the assisted living facility, where she works as a caregiver. Carly focuses on one lonely resident named Martha and decides to reunite her with an old flame by her 85th birthday. Soon, new clues sweep Carly in a harried race to the finish line where love is sure to be the ultimate prize.